History · Evidence
How we know what we know
Three layers: what kind of evidence, how reliable the source is for this use, and how confident we are in the claim.
Confidence
Rating claims, not cultures
- Confidence: High
Direct archaeological evidence or several independent lines of evidence.
- Confidence: Moderate
Plausible and supported, but not uniquely demonstrated.
- Confidence: Low
Possible, but evidence is thin or indirect.
- Confidence: Contested
Active disagreement or unresolved authenticity.
- Confidence: Unsupported
A popular claim without adequate evidence.
Confidence rates the claim, not the worth of a culture, person or source. Ancient authors can be direct witnesses and still be biased, late or rhetorical.
Every chapter has three views: Narrative (the story), Evidence (claim-level sourcing) and Debate (competing interpretations and open questions). Start reading →
Explore Trajan’s Column: ancient visual testimony and its interpretive limits →